We give you options! 

You are welcome to call us at 607-734-8799, email or chat with us, or stop in and see us. We will be glad to help you file a claim or with any questions you may have.

Do you prefer to work directly with your insurance company? Please find their information below.

Chautauqua Patrons

Click here to file a claim online
To file a claim by phone, call 800-896-4720

Dryden Mutual

Click here to file a claim online
To file a claim by phone, call800-782-0154 

Erie Insurance

Click here to file a claim online
To file a claim by phone, call 800-367-3743

Erie and Niagara

Click here to file a claim online
To file a claim by phone, call 716-632-5433

Finger Lakes Fire and Casualty

Click here to make a payment online .

To make a payment by phone, call 607-387-6831

The Hanover

Click here to file a claim online
To file a claim by phone, call800-628-0250

Midstate Mutual

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-826-8520

Millville Mutual

Click here to file a claim online
To file a claim by phone, call800-262-8495

New York Central Mutual

Click here to file a claim online
To file a claim by phone, call800-234-6926

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Click here to file a claim online
To make a payment by phone, call 844-208-1932

Progressive

Click here to file a claim online
To file a claim by phone, call800-776-4737

Safeco 

Click here to file a claim online
To file a claim by phone, call800-332-3226

Travelers

Click here to file a claim online.
To file a claim by phone, call800-842-5075

"I loved how EASY and effortless it was to start my policy.

 The staff is always friendly and helpful!"

Christena W., customer since 2017