File a Claim

We Give You Options

File a Claim

We give you options! 


You are welcome to call us at 607-734-8799, email or chat with us, or stop in and see us. We will be glad to help you file a claim or with any questions you may have.


Do you prefer to work directly with your insurance company? Please find their information below.

Chatauqua Patrons

Chatauqua Patrons

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-896-4720

Dryden Mutual Insurance Company

Dryden Mutual Insurance Company

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-782-0154

Erie Insurance

Erie Insurance

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-367-3743

Erie & Niagara Insurance

Erie & Niagara Insurance

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 716-632-5433

Finger Lakes Fire and Casualty

Finger Lakes Fire and Casualty

The Hanover

The Hanover

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-628-0250

Midstate Mutual

Midstate Mutual

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-826-8520

Millville Mutual Insurance Company

Millville Mutual Insurance Company

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-262-8495

New York Central Mutual

New York Central Mutual

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-234-6926

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Plymouth Rock Assurance

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 844-208-1932

Progressive Insurance

Progressive Insurance

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-776-4737

Safeco Insurance

Safeco Insurance

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-332-3226

Travelers

Travelers

Click here to file a claim online

To file a claim by phone, call 800-842-5075

"I loved how EASY and effortless it was to start my policy.

 The staff is always friendly and helpful!"

Christena W., customer since 2017

Share by: