Lending Your Car to a Friend is Not a Wise Idea

July 25, 2020

Good Friends are Wonderful - Them Driving Your Car May Not Be.

You have probably been there before – a good friend has found themselves without a car and has somewhere to be. Renting a vehicle may not be an option and their family vehicles are out of the question, so they come to you to ask if they could borrow your car while you’re not using it. Whether you say yes or no in that situation is ultimately your decision, but before making that decision you should consider plenty of factors that extend beyond your relationship to the person looking to borrow your car: many of those factors revolve around your insurance coverage. 

The complications that follow letting someone who is not on your insurance policy are innumerable – in short, if an accident occurs with your car while someone else is behind the wheel, chances are good that you will be found liable for any damages caused. Thankfully, your insurance should cover the expenses, but that coverage of your friend’s incident is likely to affect your rates for future coverage. An increase to your rates is more likely than not, but does depend on the terms of your insurance package. 

Some packages, however, will not fully cover accidents caused by a driver of your car who is not listed in the terms of your insurance contract. There are often exceptions to this lack of coverage if the friend who was behind the wheel lives with you or has been explicitly added to your policy prior to their instance of borrowing. There is also precedent set for degrees of coverage based on the length of the borrowing period. According to the Senior Vice President of Public Affairs for the Insurance Information Institute, Jeanne Salvatore, “... [S]ay I borrow your car to go pick up milk, and as long as permission has been verbally granted, you’ll typically be covered.”

For a FREE INSURANCE QUOTE please call us at  607.734.8799 

The primary takeaway from all of the potential coverage is that car insurance typically follows the car – not the driver. No matter what kind of insurance your friend may have, if they are behind the wheel of a car that you insure, your insurance will take the brunt of the financial burden. This is not a steadfast rule, however, and it may be the case that your friend’s insurance will follow them no matter which car they are driving.

Beyond the nuance behind are you covered and how much coverage you’ll receive from your insurance company, there is the issue of when your insurer will pay out. In the case of a driver-caused incident involving your car, but driven by a person who is not on your policy, most insurers will only pay out for damages after the driver is found legally responsible. While you may be able to find policies that pay out in advance of a legal ruling, being stranded with a bill for an accident which you did not cause is a daunting thought for everyone. 

Ultimately the decision to allow someone else to drive your car is your decision. Know the risks of handing the keys off, though, as chances are good that if something happens to the car, driver, or anyone else on the road as a result of the other person’s driving, you will be faced with the bill. Even if your insurance covers the damages, your rate has potential to increase and you may not get your reimbursement until months later.  

By Kim Wilson October 23, 2025
When it comes to insurance, it’s tempting to shop around for the lowest price — after all, who doesn’t want to save a few dollars each month? But insurance isn’t like buying a gallon of gas or a cup of coffee. The cheapest policy might save you a little upfront, but it can cost you much more in the long run. Coverage limits, exclusions, and customer service vary greatly from one company to another, and a bargain policy may leave you uncovered when you need it most. A good insurance policy should give you peace of mind, not just a smaller bill. That means choosing a plan that’s tailored to your specific needs — your home, your car, your lifestyle, and your risks. A knowledgeable local agent can help you understand what’s included (and what’s not) so you don’t find out the hard way after a claim. At Wallin Insurance, we take the time to make sure you’re properly protected, not just “barely covered.” Another key difference between cheap insurance and the right insurance is service. When something goes wrong — whether it’s a fender bender or storm damage to your home — you want a team that answers the phone, knows your name, and helps you through every step. As an independent agency, we work with multiple carriers to find the right fit for your budget and your coverage needs. We’re also your advocate when it’s time to file a claim, not just a voice on the other end of a 1-800 number. At the end of the day, buying insurance isn’t about finding the lowest price — it’s about finding the right protection and a trusted partner. At Wallin Insurance, you’ve got a friend in the business who’s here to help you make confident, informed decisions so you’re covered when it matters most.
By Kim Wilson October 9, 2025
When it comes to protecting your home, car, or business, the coverage you choose is important—but so is the person behind it. Buying insurance locally isn’t just about convenience; it’s about building a relationship with someone who truly understands your needs. At Wallin Insurance, you’ve got a friend in the business, and here’s why choosing a local agent matters. 1. Personalized Service You Can Count On A local agent knows the community and the unique risks that come with it. At Wallin Insurance, we take the time to get to know our clients personally—understanding your lifestyle, your priorities, and your concerns—so we can recommend coverage that fits your life. When questions arise or claims need attention, you can call us directly and speak to someone who knows you, not just a faceless hotline. 2. Quick and Easy Claims Assistance When the unexpected happens, speed matters. Our local agents guide you through the claims process quickly and efficiently, helping you get back on your feet without unnecessary stress. Being right here in your community means we’re invested in helping our neighbors—our clients—every step of the way. 3. Support Local Businesses and Give Back Working with Wallin Insurance means supporting a local business that actively gives back. We proudly support a variety of charities, including delivering Meals on Wheels to community members in need. Choosing us isn’t just about insurance—it’s about contributing to a stronger, more caring community. 4. Tailored Advice You Can Trust We don’t just sell policies—we build relationships. At Wallin Insurance, we help you understand your options, identify discounts you may not know about, and make sure you have the right coverage for your specific situation. That personal guidance is something you won’t get from a big online insurer. 5. Peace of Mind Knowing there’s a friendly, familiar face to turn to when life throws the unexpected your way is invaluable. With Wallin Insurance, you’ve got a friend in the business—someone who truly cares about protecting your home, family, and future. Final Thoughts Insurance is more than just a policy—it’s protection for what matters most. Choosing Wallin Insurance means personalized service, faster claims help, and the confidence of working with someone who genuinely cares about you and our community. And remember, with Wallin Insurance, you’ve got a friend in the business.
By Peter Wallin September 26, 2025
Why You Should Bundle Your Home and Auto Insurance When it comes to protecting the things that matter most, like your home and your vehicle, having the right insurance coverage is key. But did you know that combining your home and auto policies with the same insurance company can provide significant benefits? Bundling is one of the easiest ways to save money and simplify your insurance experience, all while ensuring you have strong protection in place. One of the biggest advantages of bundling is the potential for cost savings. Many insurance companies offer discounts when you purchase multiple policies through them. These savings can add up quickly, making it a budget-friendly way to secure the coverage you need. Plus, it’s a smart financial move to maximize value without sacrificing quality protection. Bundling also adds convenience. Instead of juggling multiple policies, payments, and renewal dates with different companies or agents, everything is streamlined. This makes managing your coverage easier and less stressful, especially when it comes to filing a claim. With just one agency handling your policies, you’ll also have a single point of contact for questions or assistance, saving you time and frustration. Lastly, bundling can help ensure better coverage coordination. When one insurance agency oversees your insurance portfolio, they can identify gaps or overlaps in your protection. This holistic approach helps ensure that you’re fully covered in the event of an accident, natural disaster, or other unexpected event. At an independent insurance agency, we can compare multiple carriers to find the best bundling options for your unique needs, giving you peace of mind and the best possible value.
By Peter Wallin September 15, 2025
We Have a Mural to Prove It
By Peter Wallin March 5, 2025
Auto insurance companies are facing unprecedented rate increases due to inflation and the increasing cost of repairs. One of the most simple ways to assure your auto insurance rate is providing the best value is to take a defensive driving course - which is available to you online ! For residents of New York, the Improv Traffic School is currently offering their top-rated, fully-online defensive driving course for under $30, making it easier and more affordable than ever to both become a better driver, and save on auto insurance premiums. Some benefits of taking the course include: A guaranteed reduction of up to 10% on insurance rates - The certificate is recognized by all New York State auto insurance companies. Reduction in points on your license - For people with points attached to their driving record, the Defensive Driving Course can help eliminate those marks on your driving history. A fully online learning environment - The course can be completed from the comfort of your own home, with an instant awarding of your certificate upon completion. No final exam - Anxious test-takers, worry not. The Improv School’s course is content-oriented, making the focus more about taking in information than being able to reiterate the contents of the class. The course is designed to benefit you. If your defensive driving certificate is near its expiration date, now is the perfect time to renew without going out of your way. For folks who have previously completed a Defensive Driving Course, the Improv School also offers a 3 Year Renewal Course in order for you to retain your discount. If an online course does not sound like the right choice for you, there is a classroom-style Defensive Driving Course for your consideration. The classroom-based course offers all of the same benefits as the online equivalent, including the reduction of up to 10% on your insurance rates. Whether you’ve been seeking a way to lower your premiums, or simply desire to improve your driving habits, learning more about defensive driving strategies is a simple and efficient way to start.
By Sarah Smith March 5, 2025
Updating your roof might save you money on your insurance
By Peter Wallin December 5, 2023
So your teenager is getting their drivers license? Congratulations! Sort of...
By Peter Wallin December 5, 2023
The Independent Agent is your best option
By Peter Wallin December 4, 2023
Take Care This Winter!
By Peter Wallin October 20, 2023
Watch out for Deer in the Autumn Months